Make an appointment today! 715-748-5331

We’re a Small Agency with a BIG Personal Touch!

We’re a Small Agency with a BIG Personal Touch!

We’re a Small Agency with a BIG Personal Touch!

Meet Our Staff

Whether you need auto, home, life or commercial insurance, we are here to serve you.


Lisa Schantner

I have been part of Fidelity Insurance since May of 1993. Throughout those 23 years, I took several years to stay at home and raise my 4 children. During that time I worked part time up until 2011 when I became sole owner of the agency. During the past 5 years I’ve really enjoyed the challenges of running an agency, but most of all, I’ve enjoyed working with our small communities and being able to provide great personalized service to our customers. Outside of Fidelity Insurance, I enjoy camping and spending time with my husband, Steve, and our 7 children. I also coach the Prentice/Rib Lake Hawks cross country team. Steve and I together enjoy supporting our local athletic teams and communities.


Steve Schantner

I joined the FIA team after retiring from Caterpillar in May of 2015, It has been a wonderful change! My wife and I have a blended family of 7 children. I enjoy hunting, fishing, camping, and am a HUGE fan of Wisconsin sports! My biggest joy is spending time with my family and friends. Stop by and get a quote. I also do notarizing!


Jennifer Schrader

I have been with Fidelity Insurance for over 18 years. It is very rewarding being able to work with a small community and be able to build a strong bond with clients. My husband Zane and I have four children. Our family enjoys camping, 4-wheeling, and attending sporting events in our spare time. I look forward to working with and helping you in the future.


Gary Heitkemper

I have been employed with Fidelity Insurance for over 16 years. I enjoy traveling, hunting, fishing, gardening, and keeping honey bees.


Tyler Enders

I recently graduated from Marquette University in May 2016 and joined the family business later in August. I enjoy camping with my family and friends, playing basketball, and going to the movies. I look forward to meeting you and providing the best possible service.


Leone Draeger

I began a new adventure on August 1st, 2016 with Fidelity Insurance after working at Credit Unions for the past years. My husband Bill and I have been married for 38 years and have been blessed with 2 children, their spouses, and 6 grandchildren. I enjoy knitting, golfing, riding motorcycle with Bill, hanging out of our hunting cabin, and spending time with family and friends.